Forum Discussion
Inquiry Regarding GST Calculation on Bill Credits
The answer I am referring to is the one you give in this very website about the way Telus reduces the face value of bill credits by GST application.
If you're going to claim this is mandated b...
Appreciate the response — but let’s cut through the spin.
Telus isn't required to apply GST this way. You're choosing to, because it benefits your bottom line. CRA Bulletin B-103 doesn’t force this structure. It simply explains how tax is applied if a company chooses to treat internal credits as post-sale rebates. You chose that structure — likely because it lets you charge GST on money the customer never actually spends.
There’s no “full service amount” being paid here. Customers see the discount on their invoice before payment is made. That’s not a rebate — that’s a price reduction. A true post-sale rebate means the customer is charged and pays full price, and then receives a refund later. That’s not what’s happening. You’re taxing the higher amount, even though the customer never pays it.
This isn’t a CRA requirement — it’s a Telus accounting choice. Retailers across the country apply discounts before tax without issue. The only reason to structure it this way is to maximize how much you can tax and collect — even if it’s just pennies at a time.
You’re presenting this as a legal obligation when it’s clearly a business decision. A more honest answer would be:
> “We structure credits this way so we can apply tax on the undiscounted amount.”
But that would admit the obvious — this is about revenue, not compliance.
And let’s be real: the CRA didn’t tell you to quietly archive the last thread either. That was just damage control.
