5 dots vs 5 bars

Reply

This thread's discussion is locked. If it doesn't give you the information you need, head to its forum board for active discussions or to start a new discussion.

XianNewman
Organizer
Has anyone seen the 5 dots that represent signal strength on the new iOS 7?

What do you think? Change for the sake of change? Or does this change actually remove unnecessary complexity?

To me it looks clean, simple, and while it's a bold move, of anyone Apple can pull it off.

The bars, while somewhat well understood by most, once required users to process not only the number of bars, but also the relative height of each. But don't most of today's users simply ignore the relative height and count the number of bars? If so, why not remove the height dimension and instead illustrate signal in a way that people actually process it - nothing more, nothing less.
Silver_Arrow
Ambassador

I find it to be a lot sleaker and modern then the bars. 

rgl168
Connector

Someone researched where the dots came from.  The dots in iOS7 were the nearly the same as Ive's conceptual documents filed during the Apple/Samsung lawsuit.  So Ive has the vision of the dots all along, just that he wasn't at the helm for iOS to execute his designs until recently.

 

http://www.cultofmac.com/231140/ios-7s-flat-icons-are-a-blast-from-the-past/

 

 

arkon
Friendly Neighbour

Looks nice, I suppose. Kind of weird though, since dots traditionally mean pages in iOS...

Erwin
Resident
I love it, it's different and sleek